0 Jackhill - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons She put the birdhouses up for bluebirds, cardinals, robins, finches and sparrows. She has watched neighborhood cats pull the chicks out of them

The gardener, who has lived in her suburban neighborhood for about a year, keeps her own two cats indoors. About five other cats roam through her yard on a regular basis, and she says they cause no damage “other than eating a lot of the birds.” Her story, which TwistedSifter published on Nov. 9 , ends with a question she is not proud of: should she trap them?

The lots in her neighborhood are about a fifth of an acre. She spends a lot of time gardening and enjoys watching birds at her feeders. The birdhouses were part of the plan, a way to bring nesting birds into the garden she has been building

For the cats that wander in from the surrounding houses, the setup is a buffet. Feeders draw birds down to the ground. Birdhouses hold eggs and chicks in one predictable spot. A nest box mounted where a cat can reach or wait beneath it is easy pickings

Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s NestWatch program , which guides people who put up nest boxes, includes a section on dealing with predators, because a birdhouse without protection can become a trap for the birds it was meant to help

Her experience is a small piece of a very large problem. A study by Scott Loss, Tom Will and Peter Marra in Nature Co