A 20-minute behaviour test in a shelter kennel tells you less than the cage card implies. In the largest published validation of the ASPCA Feline-ality assessment, the shelter score for confidence predicted confidence at home at 0.24; sociability predicted home sociability at 0.11, which was not significant. Those two numbers, not the nine personality labels, are what the test buys you.
What the 11-item assay measures
Feline-ality is an 11-item behavioural assay scored by a trained evaluator in one session of 20 to 25 minutes. Items feed two dimensions: Valiance, 0 to 43, for confidence and response to novelty, and Independent/Gregarious, 2 to 32, for social attitude. The pair places the cat in one of nine types. The 2015 revision dropped the old 72-hour data-card hold to a single session at least 18 hours after intake, limited to cats at least 9 months old and already sterilised.
As a description of the cat that day, that is reasonable. As a forecast, it is thin.
Where the correlations land
The 2015 validation followed adopters home and re-scored the same behaviours:
| Scored in the shelter | Compared with | Result | How to read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Valiance (confidence) | Valiance at home | 0.24, p = 0.01 | small but real |
| Independent/Gregarious | Sociability at home | 0.11, p = 0.24 | no reliable signal |
| Play, modified version | Play at home | rho 0.36, p < 0.01 | moderate |
| Play, original version | Play at home | rho 0.10, p = 0.40 | none |
| Adopter fit with lifestyle | 1 to 7 scale | median 7, both groups | ceiling effect |
Play is the most transferable item; confidence transfers weakly; sociability, the trait most adopters think they are choosing, did not transfer in that sample of 74 and 75 cats. One trait out of three, below 0.3, is a screen, not a verdict.
The 2023 evaluation: 183 files, 14.2% errors
The 2023 program evaluation in Animals is the part shelters do not quote. A controlled interrupted time series compared Seattle Animal Shelter across 2015 to 2019 with Multnomah County, Oregon: no change in adoptions, euthanasias, returns, transfers or length of stay was attributable to the program it launched in 2017.
The process audit is more useful. Of 183 assessments, 26, or 14.2%, had calculation errors and 8 produced the wrong type. Of 183 adoptions, 102 had no adopter survey on file; of the 81 that existed, 68, or 84%, carried at least one error. Only 3 cats were matched on both dimensions with no error in either instrument: 1.6%, against 45% in ASPCA design work and 4.9% at that shelter.
Why the same cat scores differently in two buildings
A 2026 study applied the protocol to 113 cats in six shelters in southern France, one evaluator per cat. Scores differed significantly between shelters on most items and both composite scales. A test that shifts with the building is partly measuring the building: noise, density, how often staff pass the cage, whether the cat has been there 2 days or 20.
The structure also fails to replicate cleanly. A Brazilian sample of 71 cats produced three factors rather than two, explaining 59.4% of variance. A 31-cat study repeating five tests three times found the scores repeatable: good for consistency, silent about the home. Repeatability asks whether two raters agree today; predictive validity asks whether the number means anything in your flat.
Reading a cat yourself in ten minutes
You do not need the card to see the parts that carry signal. In the visiting room:
- Play. Two minutes of wand toy. Stalking and pouncing under shelter stress is the one item with a moderate record, at 0.36.
- Approach. Sit still, no direct stare, count to 120. Note the distance it closes on its own, and whether it freezes at the kennel door.
- Handling. Three slow strokes on the cheek, then stop. Watch the tail tip and ears, not the purr, which cats also produce when anxious.
- History. Ask how many days it has been kennelled and whether staff have seen it eat, play and use the box. Ten days of shutdown is a kennel, not a personality.
The undersocial question is the one worth taking seriously
The Feline Spectrum Assessment asks a narrower question: is this cat socialised to people at all? In a prospective study, cats judged more likely to be undersocial were more fearful, less affectionate and less tolerant of being petted, and their adopters were slightly less satisfied. The authors recommended routing cats scored 1 or 2 to trap-neuter-return or barn placement rather than a flat. That is a placement decision, and a wrong one costs the cat a home twice.
What a 7-day trial can and cannot tell you
No randomised trial of trial adoptions exists, so treat the trial as a diagnostic, not a cure. The closest evidence is a foster study of 80 shelter cats in four groups of 20, from control to enhanced in-shelter socialisation to a one-night sleepover to a week-long foster. Short fostering gave no significant improvement in social behaviour or stress, and no rise in fear, aggression or urinary cortisol after return. Fostered cats were adopted fastest on average, but the length-of-stay gap was not significant.
Plainly: a week will not fix a frightened cat, and a calm week does not prove calm in month three. What the week gives is a list of countable events, which beats a label assigned in 20 minutes.
A trial scorecard you can fill in
Record four lines, decide once, and write the decision down before day 7. None of this replaces a veterinary behaviour consult for a cat that is biting, not eating or not using the box.
| When | What to record | Decision line |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | Litter box use within 24 hours; first meal eaten | both events, nothing more |
| Days 2 to 3 | Hiding places used; distance held at feeding time | eats with you in the room |
| Days 4 to 5 | Two 5-minute play sessions; does the cat engage | one full stalk and pounce |
| Days 6 to 7 | Three-stroke handling test; night vocalisation | tolerates handling, settles by night 3 |
| Day 7 | Lines passed out of four | 3 to 4 keep; 1 to 2 book a consult; 0 return within the window |
Before signing, ask five questions: the score and which items cost points, days kennelled, any previous home, the return policy in days, and who to call in week two. If the cat comes home with a label attached, read what a behaviour label does and does not mean first, and use the 30-minute pre-adoption check for the rest. Fostering first? The 28-day foster-to-adopt structure holds the same observations better, and a cat that starts biting needs the play, fear and overstimulation split, not a longer trial.
Frequently asked
Does a shelter's temperament test predict how a cat will behave at home?
Partly, and less than most adopters assume. In the 2015 validation of the Feline-ality assessment, the shelter confidence score predicted confidence at home at 0.24 (p = 0.01) and sociability predicted sociability at 0.11, which was not significant. Play behaviour did best in the modified version, at a correlation of 0.36. Treat the label as one input beside the cat's history, the kennel time and what you see in the visiting room.
Why did the 2023 evaluation report a 1.6% success rate?
That figure counts cats matched on both dimensions with no scoring or paperwork error in either the behaviour assay or the adopter survey. Of 183 assessments reviewed, 26 (14.2%) had calculation errors, 102 adoptions had no survey on file, and 68 of the 81 surviving surveys (84%) had at least one error. The number measures implementation failure as much as the instrument, which is why the authors say the outcome data cannot separate the two.
Is a 7-day home trial a good way to test a cat?
It is a diagnostic, not a cure. A foster study of 80 shelter cats found that one night or one week away from the shelter did not significantly improve social behaviour or lower stress, and did not increase fear or aggression afterwards. Use the week to count concrete events, such as litter box use in the first 24 hours and whether the cat eats in your presence, and decide against lines you wrote down in advance.
Related guides
- Overseas Shelter Cats: 2 Documents, 4 Tests, 30 Days
- Long-Stay Shelter Cats: 30 Days, 3 Tests, 14 to Settle
- The 5 Shelter Behavior Tests: 30 Minutes, 20-30% Wrong
- Shelter Counseling: 12 Questions in 30 Minutes
- Triple Test Before Adoption: FeLV, FIV, Fecal for 80-200
- Stray Hold Periods: 3 Days, 6 Days and the Clock on the Kennel Card